What Your Metaphor Leaves Out

Skip to article

Metaphor & authority

What Your Metaphor Leaves Out

A metaphor draws attention to certain relationships. It also offers people parts to play.

Essay · 3 minute read · The Metaphor Society

An organisation calls itself a garden.

The language promises patience, nourishment and room to grow. It also makes a role available: someone can decide what gets planted, what needs pruning and what counts as a weed.

The plants have arrived in the conversation. The gardener may still be unnamed.

The roles inside the picture

Metaphors offer more than a resemblance. They bring relationships with them. A family has obligations; a machine has interdependent parts; a marketplace has exchanges. When these pictures enter a discussion, some actions begin to sound natural.

Calling a workplace a family can make mutual care feel important. It can also make leaving on time sound like a small failure of loyalty. The same language might accompany practical support during an illness or pressure to take on another unpaid evening. Its significance lies partly in the request it carries.

A machine suggests coordination, maintenance and a search for faults. It can help explain why a missed handover interrupts everyone’s work. It can also reduce a person’s judgement to the performance of a part.

The family may be generous or overbearing; the machine flexible or rigid. Even a shared metaphor can contain different pictures.

Growth brings conditions into view.
Time, resources and care affect what becomes possible.

Gardening brings authority into view.
Someone chooses what should grow and what may be removed.

Where the picture becomes a decision

“We need to prune” can sound economical and almost seasonal. In an organisation it may mean ending a project, removing a role or reducing someone’s hours. The horticultural image does not settle which choice is warranted or who should make it.

The proposal becomes easier to examine when its borrowed scenery falls away. “End this project so that two staff can finish the other one” is an action people can examine. The resources, costs and competing commitments become available for discussion.

An appealing image can help a proposal arrive. It cannot supply all the reasons for accepting it.

A place can sustain several descriptions

A community centre may need the patience of a garden for a new reading group and the urgency of a repair schedule for its leaking roof. Care for volunteers belongs beside a clear account of their time. These descriptions can coexist because they attend to different needs.

The limits become visible in the details that resist the picture. A volunteer can decline. A colleague can disagree with the person assigning the roles. A project can be valuable without growing larger.

The centre remains a place with a roof, a budget and people whose commitments differ. Each metaphor helps describe something about it. None gets to decide what all of those people are for.

Dan Scorpio · Archived original

A connection to the archive

Metaphor and Problem Solving

The archived page explores translating a problem into another setting. This essay considers the choice of picture and the authority it lends to a proposal.

Archive opens in a new tab or window.