Grammar & viewpoint
A Day Without “Is”
E-Prime removes a familiar verb. What matters is what the revised sentence can now say.
A sentence loses “is” and keeps its certainty.
“Alex is unreliable” becomes “Alex behaves unreliably”. The forbidden verb has gone. The judgement remains almost where it was.
E-Prime is English written without forms of to be: “am”, “is”, “are”, “was”, “were”, “be”, “being” and “been”, including the relevant contractions. The restriction interrupts habit. What the writer does next determines whether the sentence improves.
Two changes that look like one
“Alex missed two meetings this month” differs from the original in a more substantial way. It names events and a period of time. The reader can understand what prompted the concern while the reasons for the absences remain open.
Two operations are easily confused here: removing a verb and replacing a broad judgement with a specific account. “Alex was absent from two meetings this month” supplies much the same useful detail while retaining “was”.
The improvement comes from what the sentence makes available to the reader. Grammar provides several routes to it.
The writer returns to the scene
“The room is oppressive” presents a quality as belonging to the room. “I felt uneasy in the room” gives the experience an observer. “The low ceiling and lack of windows made me uneasy” adds an account of what mattered to that observer.
Each version has a different scope. The last contains an explanation the writer must have reason to give. A detailed account can be mistaken; a carefully attributed belief can still lack support.
The constraint earns its place by making these choices visible.
What a revision can lose
“The volunteers are sorting books” describes activity in progress. “The volunteers sort books” can describe their usual work. Removing “are” may change the time inside the sentence.
A passive construction can also preserve an honest unknown. “The date was changed” does not identify who changed it. Naming an organiser simply to make the sentence active would invent information.
“The collection point is the side door” may already be an excellent instruction. It gives the reader something needed, in a familiar form, with little effort.
A constraint can help a writer find a sentence. The reader has to live with the sentence, not the constraint.